Superstitions and body omens

What each is said to mean — and what is actually going on.

Itchy right palm

Tradition. Money coming in — in most of Europe and North America. In parts of India and the Caribbean the sides are reversed.

Actually. Dry skin, eczema or contact irritation. Persistent itching without visible cause is worth mentioning to a doctor.

Itchy left palm

Tradition. Money going out. The mirror of the right, and equally regional.

Actually. Same as the right. Palms itch because skin is skin.

Ringing in the ears

Tradition. Someone is talking about you — right ear praise, left ear criticism. Recorded by Pliny in the first century.

Actually. Tinnitus. Common, usually benign, but sudden onset in one ear warrants medical attention.

Eye twitching

Tradition. Varies wildly by culture — good news, bad news, or a visitor, depending where you are.

Actually. Myokymia, almost always caused by fatigue, caffeine or stress. It resolves on its own.

Sneezing

Tradition. Someone thinking of you. The blessing after a sneeze survives from a belief that the soul briefly left the body.

Actually. Irritation of the nasal lining. The soul is fine.

Hiccups

Tradition. Someone is talking about you, and they will stop when you name the right person.

Actually. Diaphragm spasm. Hiccups lasting over 48 hours are considered persistent and should be looked at.

A black cat crossing your path

Tradition. Bad luck in Britain and North America; good luck in Japan, Scotland and much of continental Europe. The split traces to medieval witch panic in some regions and not others.

Actually. A cat crossed the road. Black cats are adopted from shelters at measurably lower rates because of this belief, which is the only real harm it causes.

Breaking a mirror

Tradition. Seven years of bad luck — Roman in origin, from the belief that mirrors held a piece of the soul and life renewed on a seven-year cycle.

Actually. Mirrors were extremely expensive until the nineteenth century. A superstition that made servants careful with them had obvious utility.

Spilling salt

Tradition. Bad luck, averted by throwing a pinch over the left shoulder into the devil's face.

Actually. Salt was a currency — the word "salary" comes from it. Wasting it was genuinely costly.

Why body superstitions are so consistent

Itching, ringing and twitching are involuntary, noticeable and have no obvious cause — exactly the conditions under which people generate explanations. Almost every culture has readings for them, and the readings often contradict each other across a single border, which tells you what they are worth as predictions.

What is striking is how many map onto money and gossip: the two things people most want advance warning about.

How old these actually are

Every superstition here carries a first-recorded date — the earliest point it appears in a written source. That is not the same as its origin: an unrecorded practice can be centuries older than its first mention, and we say so rather than guessing backwards.

What the dates do show is which beliefs are younger than their reputation. Friday the 13th has no source before the 19th century and entered popular culture through a 1907 novel. "Something old, something new" was first printed in 1871. "Break a leg" appears in the 1920s. The opal curse is traceable to a single book — Walter Scott's novel of 1829, after which European opal sales reportedly halved.

Others are exactly as old as claimed. The evil eye appears in Sumerian tablets from around 3000 BC and turns up independently in Greek, Roman, Jewish and Islamic sources. Body omens — itching, sneezing, ringing ears — are recorded by Pliny in the first century and have barely changed since.

The pattern worth noticing: beliefs about the body are old, beliefs about ceremonies are usually Victorian, and beliefs about performance — exams, sport, gambling — are twentieth century, because the activities themselves are.